The Beatles fan forum

(590 views)

The Enduring Legacy

An old friend of mine issued a group email the other day asking everyone he knew to send him lists of their favorite songs of all time. He was looking for a list of 20 songs... 25 tops. He wouldn't fully explain why he wanted us to do this, just said he had some vague theory he was testing out. I spent more time than I care to admit trying to compile my songs, and found the task ultimately impossible, although I did send him an unsatisfying list of 25 songs, winnowed down from an initial draft of 80. If I did it again tomorrow, I wrote him back, the list would be completely different. One interesting thing, though: When push came to shove and I had to make some hard decisions about what to cut out and what to leave on the list, I ended up rejecting more recent songs (because who knows if I'll still like those next week?) and holding onto the golden oldies with staying power. To my genuine surprise, 24 of the 25 songs in my final draft were either from my teenage years (contrary to popular belief, there were one or two good songs released in the 1980s) or were older than I am. When you grew up in the '80s, you grew up in the shadow of the Baby Boom generation, so no surprise that the Beatles, the Stones, the Who, the Doors, Janis Joplin, Hendrix - all broken up, past their prime, or dead by the time I became musically literate - formed a big part of the soundtrack of my youth. It turns out, though, that my resentful, diluted X of a generation is not alone in loving the music of the '60s. A recent Pew Research survey found that the Baby Boomers' music - most notably that of the Beatles - is universally popular across four generations of listeners, from 16-to-29-year-olds to senior citizens. No wonder the musical event of the year was arguably the re-release of what's known as the Beatles' "canon" - more than 200 original recorded tracks stretching across 14 albums - for the first time in digitally remastered format, as well as the release of the Beatles: Rock Band video game, which promises to make the group even more appealing for generations to come. *So here is the question: in your opinion, why do the Beatles live on so strong, and will they ever fade away? Is it all in the advertising, or are they truly a band never to be rivaled?
Avatar: mommyerin mommyerin - 11 September 2009 12:23am

Replies to this topic...


CaliCoyote said:
Well... I think that Led Zeppelin was the best band ever. Let the stoning begin! My nephew is only 13 and The Beatles is his favorite band. I'm not saying that I don't like them, they are just not my favorite. I think I like the dirty rocker boys better.
11 September 2009 1:21am


.S.o.S. said:
i think dirty rockers rock too , how come the pretty boys always get the attention ? lol :} x
11 September 2009 2:28am


PhilFriendly said:
I can't explain why I like the Beatles or why their appeal is so enduring. It was once said that several if not all Beatles songs could be arranged as a piece of classical music. Maybe that's why they have such a broad appeal. I my blog my top ten Beatles songs but as you say, this is subject to change as my mood changes. What do you leave in and what do you take out. Nice problem to have, I guess.
11 September 2009 11:44am


mommyerin said:
I love that everyone has their own opinion, free speech is alive and well on Absolute! :) xo
11 September 2009 2:59pm


.S.o.S. said:
free speech rocks too !! :}
12 September 2009 1:40am


robms said:
one of the things people say when challenged about particular older bands is that you must remember when they came about - I believe that the Beatles were like nothing before them (and some will say since too) and have an appeal to many people of all ages. Personally, I love much of their music, but am in a minority in my own household!
12 September 2009 6:26pm


ELObsessive said:
Having recently bought the (stereo) boxed set (have just posted my comments on this on a couple of the relevant threads), I've fallen in love with the Beatles all over again! For over two weeks now, I've just been revelling in all their wonderful albums! And am just so grateful that I grew up at a time when these geniuses were thrilling us with wonderful new songs - every single was different from the previous one, but as soon as you heard it, you always knew it was them! Their music will, I believe, live on forever - just as in the classical music field, Beethoven, Brahms, Mozart, Handel, Haydn and a select few others will also always be savoured by those who have ears to listen and the capacity to appreciate great art. And their influence on other artists is immense - as most of the major rock acts that have followed the Beatles have acknowledged. Because, apart from anything else, there are practically no types of music that the Beatles haven't at least dabbled in! Rock 'n' roll, jazz, rhythm and blues, heavy metal, bubblegum pop, folk, cabaret, psychedelia, reggae, ballads, classical ... And no, it's not hype - no amount of hype could keep a band selling records nearly 40 years after it broke up, and two of its members had died, including the most influential one of all. It will be most interesting to see how many of today's "hot acts" are still as widely-played and talked about, 40 years from now! Or even 20! Or even 10! Or even ... ;)
2 November 2009 1:16pm

Sorry, you have to be an Absolute Radio VIP to post topics or replies on this forum. Why not log-in or sign-up for free to get loads more access to Absolute Radio.
The Beatles biography
The Beatles were an English rock band, formed in Liverpool in 1960 and one of the most commercially successful and critically acclaimed acts in the... more

Musical Connections

If you like The Beatles you might also like:
John Lennon
555 fans love this act
Paul McCartney
421 fans love this act
George Harrison
282 fans love this act

More in this hour on absoluteradio.co.uk...

Matt BerryMatt Berry Icon: Arrow
He's the voice of Absolute Radio. Download his podcasts here.

John LydonLatest guests Icon: Arrow
Take a look at who's recently walked through our front door.

Christian O'Connell PodcastBreakfast Show Podcasts Icon: Arrow
Get your free download...